As a teacher in a psychology graduate school where the emphasis is on personal growth and healing, I have had ample opportunity to come in contact with multitudes of women of every stripe, shape and color. From time to time one of them and I will resonate over a wide range of harmonic chords. When we do, that’s often initially a sign that both positive transference and counter-transference are running pretty high, i.e. we’re both overlaying emotionally charged memories onto one another of significant people from each of our personal pasts. Invariably, over the time we spend together, some powerful relationship dynamics will show up inviting healing trying to happen. And in the best of all nourishing worlds, it will.
Harmonic Convergence
Tori was one of those “harmonic” students. Deeply interested in trauma and the brain, she became an informal graduate assistant. Over the weeks and months we began spending more and more time together collaborating on a number of research projects, co-creating highly energized times filled with all kinds of exciting, applied research possibilities.
One day Tori brought me a brochure describing a seminar at Esalen: The Body Keeps the Score. Bessel van der Kolk and Peter Levine were co-presenting a weekend on healing trauma through Somatic Experiencing. “Want to go?” Tori offered. “Sure,” I said. “Book us a couple of rooms.”
When we got to the highly charged environment that is Esalen, somehow or other the room reservation got bungled: they only had one room with two beds in it. “What do you want to do?” I asked. “We’ll take it,” Tori told the woman at the desk.
We walked over and dropped off our bags in the room, looked around at the two beds, one single and one double, and then headed over to the dining room for dinner.
Over garden salad, pilaf and pecan pie, Tori and I began talking about the room and the change in sleeping arrangements. At one point in the discussion, she became quite serious, looked at me and said: “Here’s the deal. I know myself pretty well. We can sleep together tonight and make love – and it will be some of the most sublime, ecstatic sex you’ve ever had – and we might continue our relationship as lovers for a year or two, but then I’ll be moving on. I’ll probably never have anything to do with you again after that. Or, we can not sleep together tonight, in which case the odds of us remaining lifelong friends increases substantially. The choice is yours.”
What followed then was one of the most memorable nights of my life.
Dyn-o-mite!
Back in the room fresh from the hot springs, we both changed into pajamas. Tori crawled into the double bed and got under the covers. I came over and propped up a pillow and got into bed beside her … on top of the covers. Along with me I’d brought my Inspiron laptop computer. I slipped in a Netflix disk and for the next ninety minutes Tori and I spent an unforgettable evening watching Napoleon Dynamite. When the movie was over, I kissed her on top of her head goodnight, and then went over to the single bed to sleep alone. Driving home from Esalen we both experienced more love, connection, innocence and joy than either of us had ever felt with sex.
Every few months, these many years later Tori and I email or talk on the phone. We didn’t buy into the powerful Illusion of Separation that becoming lovers and then breaking up often orchestrates. Occasionally we collaborate on projects, or spend time visiting together when one of us shows up in close proximity. When we do, our secret, smiley, heart-connection phrase is: “Vote for Pedro!”
Self, Respecting Women
I offer up this story for several reasons. As a brain educator and trauma researcher, I was more than familiar with Tori’s personal trauma history. As with many students training to be healers, hers was particularly painful, filled with multiple violations and betrayals by important people in her early life. Knowing how trauma, in an attempt at healing, will often draw us back into situations that replicate early overwhelming experiences, I was more than aware of that possibility unfolding between Tori and me (The poetic irony wasn’t missed by us that we were at a seminar focused on healing just such trauma as Tori’s. Reenactment between us would most likely not have led to healing in the least).
Over the years I have borne personal witness to untold suffering visited upon other graduate faculty who have succumbed to such enticing offers as Tori’s. Not only did such faculty add yet another traumatic reenactment to the already over-encumbered neural real estate of the student, but they inevitably added more trauma to their own storehouse of suffering. Promising careers became ruined, self-esteem plummeted. I’ve seen police get involved, lawyers, prosecutors … trauma upon trauma leading to suffering on top of suffering.
Even in a permissive, super-charged sexual environment like Esalen (and external environs can play a big role in such dynamics), Tori’s offer of erotic nirvana held little draw for me. My interests have long been in something greater, something much, much different. It’s something evoked by the easily remembered, child-like innocence that unfailingly arises every time I hear the rallying cry, “Vote for Pedro!” As Napoleon Dynamite himself would say … “Sweet!”
And this has to do with parenting? Maybe you need two blogs.
Thanks, Karen.
I know it’s a stretch.
The damage to Tori was done early to her by a parent.
And that’s what “the compulsion to repeat the trauma”
was trying to heal.
Best,
Mark
Love this blog Mark…..and the healing for you both was the beginning of much more to come…..us passing on to what is BEST for the children!
This topic seems fine in this forum about parenting. This is a great story, Mark. I think the ability to see into the future is key in what you and Tori did. Tori could see it, you could see it. When you’re that wise there’s nothing you can do but watch a great movie like Napoleon Dynamite. It’s actually one of my favorites. Really it is a movie about trauma (and a lama), missing parents and big boys who can’t grow up because of their lack. Pedro holds their hearts in his mind’s eye and through his still silence their dreams are broadcast to the world (I mean the school and those who haunt its venerable halls).
I wish more professionals and others in authority could hear this important message. It is so easy for an underling to long for shelter, to feel her only way to freedom is in the arms of a powerful other. Of course this never happens. This post reminds me a little bit of one on my blog in which I make reference to this universal desire to merge with what moves us. The post is called, “How Art Saved My Life.” I believe art can both liberate and contain our trauma. That’s the beauty of Netflix.
Hi Patrice. Thanks for affirming Napoleon. Some people think that a sophisticated brain science educator should be up for better fare. Those people don’t understand how important it is to examine such rigid thinking and not let it create a world of self-created suffering which those kinds of thoughts actually do.
And as for art saving lives, yours and others, one powerful argument that might be made by Alan Schore, “The Einstein of Attachment Theory,” is that because of the alternating growth of the brain’s hemispheres, traumatic memories learn to take up storage on the right side of the brain. In which case, it’s misguided at best to go looking in the left hemisphere to try to open such memories and integrate them back into active duty. Better to go exploring in the right brain. Now, let’s see, what might be a good way to go exploring in the right brain …
P.S. Patrice. Check out my friend Marla who does deep healing exploration using film as one evocative medium. I’m guessing she’s your kind of woman … http://www.marlaestes.com/classes.html
Did Tori give you permission to share these personal details?
Hi Hannah. Thanks for asking, for caretaking. Of course her real name isn’t Tori (nor is it Sharon Stone, whose photo I put in this piece). Not only did “Tori” give permission, but she asked me to publish it as a cautionary tale to other women who might be inadvertently compulsively repeating the trauma with men who aren’t necessarily looking for something much sweeter than sexual release.
Thanks for your response, Mark; I feel better about this story now. I’m curious if your choice of the word “caretaking” was intended to convey some pushback, or a critique that I had violated a boundary — I’m tending to interpret it that way. If so, that’s cool, I get it, but thought I would check.
No pushback intended at all, Hannah. I was actually ascribing care-taking motivation to you – legitmate concern that I might have inadvertently or deliberately violated Tori’s privacy and trust. I actually think the world can use more people concerned and willing to speak up about such matters.
Now, had I actually violated Tori’s trust and privacy, my response might have very well been a bit more defensive.
Once upon a time, when I was Tori (only less evolved than she is at the time of your story) I wish I’d looked like Sharon Stone – that would have been sweet. But I digress.
Been there, done that. Both with re-traumatizing and with good boundaries. We know which one I choose today! :-))
Thing is, my days of hands-on parenting were happening at the same time that I was promising sublime nights of sexual happiness to men who could help me re-enact my trauma. The two are inextricably linked.
As you and I both agree, the best thing a parent can offer a child is their own personal growth. It’s not the only thing, but I do believe it is the best thing. Therefore, one blog, not a stretch (even though at times I have caught myself wondering and then realized it works.)
Thank-you for another opportunity for a reflective moment or two in my Sunday.
Hi Caitlyn,
I’m sure there are many, many Tori’s out there. “Poaching” is rife in academia based upon my limited observations. Lots of unskillful retraumatizing happening over and over again, mostly with very little awareness of the damage that can result. It’s for this, and other reasons – especially things that happen in childhood that go unnoticed and unaddressed – that emotional trauma has been called “The Silent Epidemic.” It adversely affects everything from impulse control, to creativity, to immune function. All we need do is look at the Kaiser Permanente ACE study for confirmation.
And yes, from my perspective the best thing any parent can do for their children is to work to manage their own emotional reactivity, wild mind and loving heart. Address those elements and the day to day events will pretty much take care of themselves, joyfully.
Continued blessings on the journey,
Mark
Mark – Thank you for having the insight and strength to serve as a healing agent in your own and Tori’s life and thank you as well for your transparency in sharing your story on your blog today. It matters to me because for the last seven years I have been praying that God would bring into my life that which will create true, transformative healing for me from my own trauma wounds and your blog seems to be part of God’s response to my prayer.
About twelve years ago many lives were turned upside down when the very same thing happened to me. I was a “Tori” who had just been married less than two years before I started a psychology graduate program. Four years later after a gradually intensifying emotional connection with a professor fueled by the excitement of highly productive and successful work together and unhealed trauma histories that we each carried, we began a sexual relationship. Well aware of the destructive, smothering shame I was experiencing because of our relationship, I tried multiple times to privately stop the sex and still maintain a positive working relationship with the professor. Unfortunately, the professor was not nearly as educated as you about the psychodynamics and neuroscience of relationships and the reasons for the transference and counter transference between us. He persistently resisted my objections because he believed there was nothing wrong with each of us being married to other people and “in love” with each other, too. Incredibly confused, I relented and resumed and then stopped again the affair a total of 5 times. About eighteen months after I ended the sexual part of our relationship for the last time he finally understood that I was not ever going to have sex with him again and our work together painfully and abruptly ended after he retaliated against me in a very public and shaming way.
Since then, I have been seeking healing from the additional trauma of that experience as well as the earlier trauma that led me into that relationship with him. Intuitively, I had a growing sense at the time that what was happening was oddly familiar. Sensory and emotional memories of the past would flood my mind unpredictably and I became more and more conscious of a connection between the events of my life before I met the professor and the events occurring during that relationship. But lacking anyone as knowledgeable as you to confide in (in spite of seeking therapy numerous times), I could never really make sense of it all until I went back to school last Fall to obtain a degree in…wait for it…marriage and family therapy!
Will my greatly damaged neurology prevent me from being a healing agent for others as a therapist, I do not know yet. The article you referenced titled The Body Keeps the Score makes me concerned that it may. So, can you please point me in the direction of any resources that might help me maximize the possibility of healing my emotional and neurological wounds? I really do not want to let my past determine my future….
Thank you again for the work you are doing and any additional information you can share!
Hi Mary,
Thanks for having the courage and taking the time to share your story here. This is an easy maze to get lost in, particularly because it’s connected to life’s primary urge to reproduce life. It becomes especially difficult if we weren’t taught as young children to pay attention to how things feel in our stomach (The Second Brain) and in our heart – the home of self-compassion.
Here’s a page of healing resources I put together several years ago …
http://committedparent.wordpress.com/2008/03/12/effective-neuro-somatic-healing-modalities/
In truth, there’s a part of me that thinks ANY modality can be effective, so long as we trust and deeply resonate with a practitioner who’s desire and intention is our healing and well-being. Nevertheless, it can still be very challenging, exhausting, painful work that often involves uncovering and grieving losses we didn’t even realize we’d suffered.
Continued blessings to you as well on the journey. ~ Mark
P.S. Based upon your own struggles and hard work in having healing trying to happen, I would imagine you’d be a great marriage and family therapist.
Perhaps training in the causes and cures for trauma as well as the limbic-prefrontal cortex relationship might one day become a standard part of training for any position of authority from teaching to clergy to coaching to business to politics; maybe this would help at-risk authorities to keep their pants on for the the good of others and their own enlightened self-interest.
Beyond the liger as pretty much a favorite animal, my pretty much favorite neurological animal would have to be half lizard and half Buddha 🙂
In the meantime, I’ll vote for Pedro too.
Hi Bruce. That kind of training is certainly one aim I have. I totally resonate with Bruce Perry’s observation that no matter what business you’re in, first and foremost you’re in the brain change business. Change the brain – change the world.
Change the world and your wildest dreams will come true and … you automatically Vote for Pedro!
Best,
Mark
As you can probably guess, I LOVE this story. Just hearing it felt healing…an antidote for all the times that the boundary was crossed, and I became re-traumatized.
Many thanks
~ Marla